30 août 2013

ECtHR re-establishes Khodorkovskiy’s wealth, 11082/06

-->

 
Mikhail Khodorkovskiy, former Yukos head and current prisoner, achieved a huge victory in Strasbourg. The biggest Russian oil company was convicted in tax and business fraud.

It was liquidated leaving $ 9.2 billion of unsatisfied liabilities (§ 18). Together with Platon Lebeder, former Yukos director, he was ordered to pay the State all remaining tax liabilities of Yukos (§ 227), since they were de facto organisers and beneficiaries of the tax evation scheme (§ 319). The Russian Courts held that there is a subsidiary liability of managers if the corporate taxpayer had no assets (§ 875). Russians considered that owners used the limited liability company as a façade for fraudulent action, and therefore piercing of the corporate veil was an appropriate solution for defending the rights of its creditors, including the State (§ 877).

However the Strasbourg judges considered that, as a matter of principle, the Russian law did not provide for the recovery of unpaid company taxes from the managers guilty of tax evasion (§ 875). Such a practice was not “adequately accessible and sufficiently precise” (§ 876) or “clear” (§ 877).

If unpaid taxes are claimed as “damages”, the ECtHR analyses national expressis verbis law, Article 1068 of the Russian Civil Code must apply, which provides that damage caused by an employee of the company while performing his official duty must be compensated by that company (§ 879).

Article 56 of the Russian Civil Code previews personal liability of owners and managers in cases when they caused insolvency of their company. The Strasbourg judges replied that this Article was not applied in the Khodorkovskiy case, since (§ 880):
1)      The claim of the tax authorities was granted while the corporate taxpayer still existed.
2)    Article 56 provides subsidiary liability of owners and managers, while Khodorkovskiy and Lebedev were ordered to recover the amounts on the solidary basis with the company.
3)      Article 56 was not mentioned in Russian judgments.

In addition, in internal case I and K, 11/01/2001, the Russian Supreme Court interpreted the law as not allowing for the shifting of liability for unpaid company taxes from the company to its executives (§§ 449 & 882).

2 commentaires:

Ji Yeon a dit…
Ce commentaire a été supprimé par l'auteur.
Ji Yeon a dit…

Thanks for sharing, nice post!

Máy ru võng tự động hay vong tu dong là một món quà vô cùng ý nghĩa cho bé yêu của bạn, máy đưa võng tự động giúp cho các bé có giấc ngủ ngon hơn mà vong tu dong cho be không tốn sức ru võng của bố mẹ. Võng tự động hay vong dua em be chắc chắn, gọn gàng, dễ tháo xếp, dễ di chuyển và may dua vong dễ dàng bảo quản. Những lợi ích mà máy đưa võng mang lại là vô cùng thiết thực.

Chia sẻ kinh nghiệm trị tiêu chảy cho bé bằng cà rốt hay cà rốt trị tiêu chảy cho bé hiệu quả, những thực phẩm giúp cải thiện trí nhớ hiệu quả, bí quyết trị sẹo thâm bằng rau má, chia sẻ kinh nghiệm bé ăn gì để thông minh hơn hay thực phẩm giúp trẻ thông minh hơn, mẹo hay giúp trẻ thích ăn rau hay cách giúp trẻ hạ sốt nhanh hiệu quả hay làm cách nào để trẻ hạ sốt nhanh các mẹ cần biết, bệnh viêm khớp không nên ăn gì, một số mẹo giúp giảm độ cận thị cho bạn, bí quyết chống nắng với cà chua cực hiệu quả hay những thực phẩm giúp tóc mọc nhanh hiệu quả, cách giúp bé ngủ ngon giấcthực phẩm giúp bé ngủ ngon mẹ nên biết, chia sẻ cách làm trắng da toàn thân bằng thực phẩm, những món ăn chữa bệnh mất ngủ giúp ngủ ngon, mách mẹ mẹo giúp bé không sốt khi mọc răng hay làm sao để trẻ không bị sốt khi mọc răng

Những thực phẩm giúp làm giảm tại http://thucphamlamgiam.blogspot.com/
Những thực phẩm tốt cho tại http://thucphamtotcho.blogspot.com/
Những thực phẩm tốt cho da tại http://thucphamtotchoda.blogspot.com/