31 juil. 2011

ECtHR: freedom of expression allows a journalist to say that a wine is “shit”, Uj, 23954/10

Hungarian Supreme Court made a reprimand to journalist Péter Uj for characterizing wine produced by T.Zrt  as “shit”, i.e defamation violating the right to good reputation (§§ 8-9). He wrote: “hundreds of thousands of Hungarians drink this shit with pride, even devotion” (§ 6), and the ECtHR understood him.

The ECtHR concluded that this reprimand had been unnecessary in a democratic society, that there was no pressing social need (§ 19) to sanction the wine expert. The judges focused on the purpose of the word “shit” that was not to insult but to serve merely as a stylistic decoration (§ 20), since calling a low quality wine “shit” is a common practice (§ 24). In this context, “shit” is not defamation but a value judgment raising awareness about the disadvantages of the economic policy (§ 23).

1 commentaire:

Anonyme a dit…

Have you ever thought about adding a little bit more than just your articles?
I mean, what you say is fundamental and everything.
However think of if you added some great visuals
or video clips to give your posts more, "pop"! Your content is excellent but
with pics and videos, this blog could definitely be one of the very best in its field.

Amazing blog!

my homepage ... air max 90 baratas